Joshua Torres
This
is a case that has always stuck with me a bit because of the
gruesomeness of the crime, let alone the fact that the man who
prosecutors say was behind the viciousness was actually a friend of
the victim. When you add the stupidity of the perpetrators it makes
the case even more senseless and callous.
Twenty
year old Kimberly Antonakos disappeared in the early morning of March
1, 1995 from Queens New York. Kimberly was the daughter of divorced
parents and her father was a very wealthy and successful business
man. He was in the business of computers and in 1995 that area was
booming! Within hours it seems that Thomas Antonakos knew his
daughter was missing and contacted the police. The search began and
many of Kimberly's friends helped search for her, including Joshua
Torres. Joshua, his girlfriend and their young toddler were staying
with Kimberly at the time she disappeared while they waited for their
new apartment to be ready to move in. For almost four days there
were no clues as to where Kimberly could have been.
Then
in the late night of March 4th, firefighters were called
to a fire at an abandoned home. After the fire was put out a body
was found inside the basement of the home, tied to a chair. The body
would be identified as Kimberly Antonakos. An autopsy would determine that she had been alive when the fire occurred although whether she was conscious was unclear. Her car would be found
some three to four days later but the clues would end there and for
the next six months it seems investigators had few to no leads.
Then
in September of 1995 investigators would get the lead that they say
would break the case. It started with a burglary of a home. The
lead came from a burglary but it was unclear as to if the lead came
from the perpetrator of the burglary or the victims. At any rate it
led to the arrests of Joshua Torres and Nicholas Libretti. It was
alleged that another man, named Jose Negron, was also involved but in
June of 1995 he was shot in the head while walking down the street
with his young son. In the process of things not only would Torres
and Libretti be charged with kidnapping, murder and arson, Torres
would also be charged in the murder of Jose Negron.
As
most of us involved in true crime know, the U.S. Supreme Court
reinstated the death penalty in 1976 but throughout the years the
states have taken on their own stance. New York had abolished the
death penalty in 1984 but the murder of Kimberly Antonakos would
revive the often debated subject and rile up the residents of the
state. Neither Torres or Libretti could face the death penalty for
their role in Kimberly's death but it appears that citizens believed
they should have and it was later in that year that the death penalty
was reinstated once again. Executions continued apparently until
2004 when the New York appeals court found the law, as it was written
as unconstitutional. In 2007 they were officially once again
abolished and remain so in 2017.
It
seems that the person with the most information to provide
investigators in this case was a man by the name of Julio Negron (no
relation to Jose, or so it says). As I stated earlier it is unclear
as to whether Julio was the perpetrator in the burglary that occurred
and blew this case open. Regardless of his involvement in the
burglary, Julio would tell investigators that Torres had told him
that he, along with the others, had kidnapped Kimberly in order to
extort money from her father. Prosecutors would later say that while
Julio knew about the crime and was privy to information both before
and after her death he was not involved in the planning or the
execution of the plans. Defense attorney's apparently would
disagree. They would later argue that Julio Negron had “framed”
Joshua Torres. To be fair, I found no evidence of this.
In
November of 1996 Joshua Torres would go on trial. Prosecutors would
claim that Torres was the mastermind behind the crime and that he had
pushed both Jose Negron and Nicholas Libretti to kidnap Kimberly as
she returned home after a night out. They would ambush her as she
got out of her car, put tape across her eye and mouth, bound her
hands behind her body and place her in the trunk of her car. They
then drove her to the abandoned house where they would bound her to a
pole in the basement of the home. According to prosecutors Torres
would make a tape of some sort in which he would demand $75,000 from
Kimberly's father for her release. However, prosecutors would
describe Torres as a “moron” because when he called Thomas
Antonakos' phone, he did not wait for the answering machine to stop
playing so that it would record so Thomas never received the calls,
or at least not the demands. It appears that this was done on more
than one occasion. In the meantime Torres was in contact with Thomas
appearing to help him search for his daughter.
While
Torres thought he was demanding money from Kimberly's dad, she
remained tied up in the home without any food, water, or blankets to
keep her warm in freezing temperatures for almost four days.
Finally, according to information that prosecutors received, not only
was Torres angry that he had not heard back from Thomas Antonakos,
but when they returned to the abandoned home they would find Kimberly
unconscious. It was never made clear as to whether Torres believed
Kimberly was already dead at this point or just realized that things
had gone too far. It was then that idea of setting fire, not just to
the house but to Kimberly was set into motion. According to
prosecutors it was Torres who poured gasoline on Kimberly''s body
while the others helped pouring it around the home and it was Torres
who lit the match and set things ablaze.
At
his trial Torres maintained his innocence, at least to a point. He
would never, not even apparently to this day, admit to murdering
Kimberly but it does seem he that he has eluded to being behind the
kidnapping at times. Other times he simply claims full innocence.
In my research I came across a statement that has been made by Torres
since his trial back in 1996 and he claims total innocence and blames
his court appointed lawyer for keeping him quiet. And, in all of the
research that I did there was only one other site that told a
completely different story than any of the others and I suspect
Torres, or a completely delusional fan of his is behind it. Aside
from those two versions, it seems that the prosecutors theory of the
case, based on the information and evidence they had appears to be as
close as possible to the real story.
After
a two week trial and nine hours of deliberation the jury returned
with a verdict of guilty in six of the seven counts that Torres
faced. The only charge in which he was found not guilty was the
charge of murder when it pertained to Jose Negron. Prosecutors had
argued that Torres killed Jose Negron when he learned that Negron was
having issues with his conscious with what they had done and Torres
feared that he would tell the authorities. Julio Negron would tell
the jury that Torres admitted killing Jose Negron had also made a
tape about what happened and Torres feared that would get out. What
this verdict tells me is that when it came to the murder of Kimberly,
they had way more than the word of someone, they had to have the
evidence to back it. Since he could not face the death penalty in
December of 1996 Torres was sentenced to fifty-eight years to life in
prison and remains there today. His first chance at parole is not
until the year 2045.
After
Torres' trial Nicholas Libretti faced a jury. He too was found
guilty and sentenced to the same fifty-eight years to life sentence.
Libretti would die in prison in 1999 at the age of twenty-three. I
attempted to do a search on what happened but I was unable to
determine anything.
Kimberly's
father, Thomas Antonakos, lived to see his daughter's killers receive
justice but he would die in 2005, many say of a broken heart. Thomas
always maintained that he would have paid whatever amount someone
wanted to get his daughter but never heard a word. I mentioned
earlier there was one other site that told a different story than the
others and in that one it was claimed that Thomas had received the
ransom calls and refused to pay, there is nothing that I have found,
seen or heard that supports this.
Did they(Joshua and Kimberly) had daughter?
ReplyDeleteNo
DeleteNo
DeleteHi Susan, Libretti died in prison in 1999 of aids. I saw it on a show called psychic investigators, season 1, episode 9 "Burning Betrayal"
ReplyDeleteWatching it right now July 29 2018
DeleteIt's been a long time since thia happened, just today I knew it and all what I can say is that I am really sorry about her father. I can't imagine how much he suffered! Poor Tom! 💔😟😯
ReplyDeletei am related to one of them :/
ReplyDeleteYou’re related to one of the killers? It must have awful for the family. Or at least the close family members.
Delete